Which is closer to the original work, Sister Lin in the new version of A Dream of Red Mansions or Sister Lin in the 87 version?

Generally speaking, the two sisters Lin have their own merits. After all, the two directors won't choose them for no reason.

The 87 version of Sister Lin seems to have a higher voice, which I personally think is good. Dressing up looks very sad, and her acting temperament is a model of Lin Daiyu. So it is even more praised.

The new version of Sister Lin, at first glance, will think that her face is more like Baochai. But after watching a few episodes, I will feel that there are also good places. Although the acting is tender, it also has feelings. Temperament, melancholy breath is very strong. In addition, the new version is closer to the narration of the original, and the modern lighting photography is clearer and more realistic, which is very interesting.

The 87 version of Sister Lin is more popular with the public and can be said to be closer to the original; But many details are better in the new version.