Why did Zhuge Liang kill Ma Su instead of Guan Yu?

In the battle of Jieting, Ma Su made a written pledge to fulfill a military order. Later, he lost the street pavilion and Zhuge Liang killed him.

Huarong Road, Guan Yu issued a military order. Later, Guan Yu released Cao Cao privately, but Zhuge Liang released him.

It is also a military order. Why should Ma Su die and Guan Yu not?

There is a simple reason.

Guan Yu is Liu Bei's sworn brother. He eats at the table and sleeps in bed. There is no difference between you and me except his wife. The affection between these brothers is hard to feel, which is beyond the comparison of ordinary people.

Liu Bei and Guan Yu are brothers, and Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang are superiors and subordinates, so they are definitely not as good as the former.

What's more, Zhuge Liang joined halfway. When he first joined, he didn't immediately become a strategist as the Romance of the Three Kingdoms said, but played a role similar to that of an adjutant without any real official position.

At that time, Guan Yu had been asked by Cao Cao to become the pavilion of Emperor Xian of Han Dynasty. This title is officially certified, and its gold content is much stronger than that appointed by Liu Bei. Therefore, Guan Yu was proud of it all his life and loved to show off wherever he went. I'm Han Shouhou Ting Ye? A typical poor man became a rich man.

Later, Liu Bei occupied four counties in Jingzhou and rewarded Guan Yu for his meritorious service. Guan Yu was named Xiangyang satrap and bandit general, and Zhuge Liang was named commander. At this time, Zhuge Liang's rank was similar to Guan Yu's, but his real power was much smaller than Guan Yu's.

After Liu Bei occupied Yizhou, Guan Yu was appointed as Jingzhou Pastor, and Zhuge Liang was appointed as general strategist. The rank remains the same, but Guan Yu is still slightly stronger than Zhuge Liang in actual strength.

Therefore, regardless of status, official position or reputation, it is not as good as Zhuge Liang of Guan Yu. How dare you chop Guan Yu? In fact, Zhuge Liang not only dared not cut off Guan Yu's head, but also tried to please Guan Yu!

Liu Bei promoted Ma Chao to the rank of General of Five Tigers. Guan Yu refused to accept this. He wrote a letter to Liu Bei, saying that he would go back to Chengdu and try his martial arts with Ma Chao. When Liu Bei saw it, his forehead was sweating. He wondered who would guard Jingzhou if Guan Yu came back, so that Jingzhou would not be in danger.

Zhuge Liang saw it and said with a smile, I'm worried about my official duties. I'm going to write a letter to Yunshang and save it to convince him! ?

Zhuge Liang wrote:? Ma Chao is very powerful, but compared with your handsome man, he is still a little inferior! ?

Guan Yu opened the letter and read it. He smiled. The one who knows me best is Kong Ming! This boy has a good eye! ? Guan Yu showed off around with a letter written by Kong Ming.

Zhuge Liang's letter, although it resolved the dispute, also killed Guan Yu, making Guan Yu more complacent and thinking that Lao Tzu was the best in the world. Later, Guan Yu's forehead was hot, and he finally made a big mistake and lost Jingzhou. Zhuge Liang is also responsible for this. If it weren't for flattery and giving Guan Yu a wake-up call from time to time, perhaps Guan Yu wouldn't be guilty. Of course, this is another story!

Therefore, even if Zhuge Liang was given ten thousand courage, he wouldn't dare to kill Guan Yu. Guan Yu's power of life and death is only in the hands of one person, and that person is Liu Bei.

As for Ma Su, Zhuge Liang is in charge of life and death.

Ma Su is Ma Liang's younger brother, and Ma Liang is Zhuge Liang's good buddy. Before Ma Liang died, he entrusted Ma Su to Zhuge Liang to take care of him.

Zhuge Liang lived up to expectations and took good care of Ma Su. He always carries it with him and teaches him in detail. Seven capture Meng Huo, put forward by Ma Su? Attack the city for the bottom, attack the heart for the top? Zhuge Liang appreciated Ma Su's strategy very much, trusted him more from now on, and trained him as a successor.

During the first Northern Expedition, Zhuge Liang pushed for conformity, excluding veteran veterans such as Wei Yan and Wu Yi, and made incompetent Ma Su a pioneer.

Zhuge Liang arranged this for Ma Su to make contributions, so as to take this opportunity to promote Ma Su.

However, Ma Su is an unaffordable soldier. Zhuge Liang made an almost foolproof defense plan for him, but he had to do it. As a result, the street pavilion fell down, and the first northern expedition fell short.

Ma Su hit Zhuge Liang in the face, but he still pressed on the ground and slapped him several hundred times.

Zhuge Liang lost face!

At that time, many people were waiting to see jokes!

Among these embarrassed people, there are veteran cadres such as Wei Yan and Wu Yi, and there are also local gangs and Dongzhou gangs in Yizhou, waiting to see how Zhuge Liang handles Ma Su!

It would be nice if Zhuge Liang would show mercy and let Ma Su go. If they make mistakes in the future, you Zhuge Liang must also show mercy, so that Shu will be in a mess!

So Zhuge Liang will shed tears when beheading Ma Su, not to mention Ma Su, even his own son, I'm afraid he will be killed!