Evaluation of A Dream of Red Mansions

(1) Your story, according to yourself, is very interesting, so I want to be famous by writing it here. In my opinion, the first one is that there is no dynasty age to test; Second, there is no good governance that is loyal to the imperial court and customs, but only a few strange girl, who are madly in love or infatuated, or small but slightly good.

(2) Only based on their own things, but fresh and unique ... These women who I have watched and listened to for half a lifetime dare not say that they are better than everyone in the previous generation of books, but their deeds can also make them feel relieved; As for a few crooked poems, you can also spray rice for wine. During the ups and downs, ups and downs, there are traces to follow, and I dare not experience it at all until I lose the truth.

(3) The general idea is nothing more than talking about love, and it is only a record of things. There is no obscene disease when it hurts.

(4) The poem says:

The paper is full of absurd words, a bitter tear!

Dou Yun's author is crazy, who can understand the taste? 1, Wang Xilian's General Comment on Flower Protection Masters;

(1) The Story of the Stone is also about dreams, but with different ideas. Before and after the two big dreams, they all went to the dreamland. One is a real dream, although reading and listening to songs, but at a loss; First, fugue, destiny takes a hand's fate, clearly remember. While half of Zhen's dreams are dreamland, Jiang's dreams are vague, Zhen Baoyu's dreams are changing, and Lin Daiyu's dreams are becoming more and more infatuated. When Liu Xianglian woke up and became a monk, Xiangling dreamed of writing poems. Baoyu's dream combined Zhen Baoyu's dream of Miaoyu and Xiaohong's infatuation. The dream sister of Second Sister You advised to behead a jealous woman, and the dream girl of Xi 'an robbed the brocade horse. Baoyu's dream went to the nether world, attacking people and dreaming about Baoyu, Qin's, Yuan Fei and other things. Baoyu wanted to dream without dreams. It is different from other novels about dreams. A scholar's mind is incredible.

(2) In a book, Momo wrote poems and songs, artistic letters, operas, couplets, wine riddles and riddles, and told jokes, all of which were excellent; Skills include piano, chess, calligraphy and painting, medical astrology, and crafts, planting flowers and fruits, raising birds and cooking with needles. There are evil characters, chastity and stubbornness, virtue and heroism, strength and cowardice. The female generals, foreign poets, immortals and ghosts, nuns, prostitutes, slave servants, thieves and demons, drunkards and rogues of the previous generation all have colors; These deeds are prosperous banquets, extravagant and profane, honest and upright, court ceremonies, ups and downs celebrations, prison sentences, satirical altars, trade drilling, and everything is complete; Even at the end of his life, he died suddenly, accidentally, committed suicide, jumped into a river and jumped into a well, was forced to hang a beam, swallow gold, take poison, and smashed the steps to remove sperm. It can be described as all-encompassing, all-encompassing, which is invisible in other novels!

2. Julian's general comment on the master of Mingzhai:

(1) There are no straight pens, blunt pens, duplicate pens and idle pens in the book, and all of them are rendered on the side, back, front and back. It is decorated, cut and placed inside. Either recite it in advance and then change it, or make up what you recited before in your spare time. The brushstroke is delicate and unpredictable. Always get the deep feeling outside the pen and the scene at that time.

(2) The author knows everything, from poetry and prose, piano theory, painting interest, to acrobatics such as medical astrology, playing chess and singing, and Nishino Rupert, and his words are all to the point. Cao Cao is the only one who wants to play eight games. All 120 books can be summed up in three words: new, true and written.

3. Zhang Xinzhi read A Dream of Red Mansions:

This is a narrative, mainly using the methods of Warring States Policy, Historical Records and Su San. The Story of the Stone was born in The Journey to the West, borrowed from Jin Ping Mei and absorbed into Water Margin.

4. Qi Guo Sheng's Preface to the Story of the Stone:

I listened to two songs by Jiang Shu, one in my throat and the other in my nose. Huang Hua has two letters, the left wrist can open letters, and the right wrist can grass. God is skilled, I don't know. There are two songs today, regardless of throat and nose, two songs without area, one song and two songs in one hand. This is a rare thing, and it won the book "Stone". Hey! It's different.

5. Red inkstone's Dream of Red Mansions:

(1) This book only focuses on boudoir, so simply speaking, things in boudoir should not be called injustice if they involve some foreign affairs. This book dares not interfere with the court. Anyone who has to use court affairs can only take it out with a pen. The furious dare not write the children's pen and ink on the court, nor can it be said that they are unprepared.

(2) the poem says:

Floating life is very bitter and busy, and the banquet is finally over.

Sorrow and joy are still illusory, and ancient and modern dreams are absurd.

Men's words are tearful in tea, more infatuated and bitter.

It's extraordinary that you have worked hard for ten years. Mao Zedong 1

(1) (formerly China) Except for its vast territory, large population and long history, there is a Dream of Red Mansions in literature, and many places are inferior to others, so we can't be proud.

(2) A Dream of Red Mansions should not only read novels, but also look at history. He wrote a very detailed and meticulous social history.

Jin Ping Mei is the ancestor of A Dream of Red Mansions. Without Jin Ping Mei, A Dream of Red Mansions could not be written. However, the author of Jin Ping Mei does not respect women, while A Dream of Red Mansions and Strange Tales from a Lonely Studio respect women.

2. Lu Xun

(1) A Dream of Red Mansions is known to many people in China. At least, it is a title book. Who are the authors and successors? Just because of the reader's eyes, there are all kinds of things: Confucian scholars look at the Book of Changes, Taoists look at obscenity, gifted scholars look at lingering, revolutionaries look at rows of people, and gossips look at palace secrets. ...

(2) What is written in the book is nothing but mixed feelings and traces of gathering and scattering, while the accidents of the characters get rid of the old stereotypes, which is very different from previous human novels.

(3) As for the value of A Dream of Red Mansions, it is really rare in China's novels. Its main point is to dare to describe it truthfully without any taboo. It is completely different from the previous novels describing good people and bad people, so the characters described in it are all real people. In short, since the publication of A Dream of Red Mansions, the traditional thinking and writing methods have been broken. -the charm and lingering of his article is second.

3.hu shi

Because A Dream of Red Mansions is Cao Xueqin's self-narrative of "hiding the truth", he is not afraid of triviality and repeatedly describes his family's transition from rich to poor. We never look at Cao Yin's life history like a corrupt official; His family came down, and his son went bankrupt. It may be that the family loves spending money and putting on airs. Pay attention to eating and drinking, pay attention to the scene; Collect fine books and engrave them; Make friends with literati and celebrities, make friends with aristocratic officials and entertain the emperor. As for four times and five times; They can't manage money and refuse to save; I'm used to paying attention to profligacy and can't back down: I even lose money or go bankrupt. A Dream of Red Mansions is only an honest description of this natural trend of "sitting on an empty mountain" and "falling apart". Because of this, A Dream of Red Mansions is a masterpiece of naturalism.

4. Wang Guowei

(1) A Dream of Red Mansions is philosophical, cosmic and literary. The reason why this dream of red mansions is so contrary to the spirit of our country lies in its value.

(2) A Dream of Red Mansions, contrary to all comedies, is a complete tragedy!

5. Yu Pingbo

The first skill of the author of A Dream of Red Mansions is that he is good at writing human feelings. Look carefully, no one is out of date when writing a book, and no one has gone too far; The same is true for writing things and scenery. A dream of red mansions is self-pitying, self-conscious and confessional, so it can't be written by itself. Moreover, his materials are practical and cannot be reversed at will, so he wants to break the mold and offend readers. The author didn't know it unconsciously at that time, but the end of A Dream of Red Mansions always won a great victory and made great achievements. The first skill of the author of A Dream of Red Mansions is to tell the truth and be a fair mirror.

6. Huang Zunxian

A dream of red mansions is the first good novel from ancient times to the present, and it should win glory with the sun and the moon.

7. Cai Yuanpei

The Story of the Stone is also a political novel of the Kangxi Dynasty in the Qing Dynasty. The author is very loyal to nationalism, and his skill in the book is to hang out the demise of the Ming Dynasty and expose the loss of the Qing Dynasty, especially in the sense of regretting those who are Han officials. 1, UK

(1) 1892, Preface to China's Translation of A Dream of Red Mansions: As a student, I must be in the grand maze of a Dream of Red Mansions.

(2) Encyclopedia Britannica (19 10): A Dream of Red Mansions is a very advanced work with complicated plot and originality.

(3)2065 438+04 Daily Telegraph: This epic is written in vernacular rather than classical Chinese. There are more than 400 characters in the book, with two branches of an aristocratic family as the main line, telling a sad love story, full of humanistic spirit.

2. Germany

1932, Postscript of Kuhn's German translation of A Dream of Red Mansions: How can such a Europe, which cares about spiritual civilization, ignore and forget this huge and complete artistic work and cultural monument for a hundred years?

3. Russia

19 In the 1980s, Vasiliev: A Dream of Red Mansions was so beautifully written and interesting that imitators had to be produced!

4. France

198 1 year, the French version of A Dream of Red Mansions was officially published. Express Weekly commented that the complete translation of this masterpiece has now been published, filling a painful gap for two centuries. In this way, it seems that people suddenly discovered Cervantes and Shakespeare. We seem to find that French classical writers Proust and Ma are tired of their painstaking efforts and decide to work together to complete such a masterpiece of genius. A Dream of Red Mansions is a masterpiece of cosmology. Cao Xueqin has Brewster's keen eyes, Tolstoy's sympathy, Samuel's clever humor, Balzac's insight and the ability to reproduce all social strata from bottom to top.