Is the folklore "the story of Guan Yu Zangetsu leaving Sim" a real person or a shadow?

1, the first version is the story of Diusim becoming a monk. He wrote the zaju "The Secret of Jinyun Hall" anonymously, expounding his political contribution to the world, and finally died of a nun.

2. The second folk version claims that the story of Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei escorting Diusim returned to his hometown of Muer Village, and Diusim's story remained faithful, never married, and finally became a virtuous old woman, which was built as a memorial by the villagers. In order to make a living and enrich people's literary life, Dixim's story also organized a troupe performance, and the stage she built once became an attractive attraction in the village.

3. In the third version, the story of Diusim is that Liu saved him, left with Lu Bu's daughter and son, changed his name and surname, and lived a happy life. Occasionally, I put down my work, leaned against the window and recalled the dreamlike days with Lu Bu.

When we often talk about the Three Kingdoms, many heroes will appear before our eyes, such as Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang, Guan Yu, Cao Cao and so on. In the troubled times of the Three Kingdoms, the short time does not affect his greatness.

During the Three Kingdoms period, the appearance of beautiful women should also be a beautiful scenery. At the beginning of the Three Kingdoms, the story of Diusim should also become a bright spot in many people's hearts. She was Wang Yun's maid, but in the face of Dong Zhuo and Lu Bu, she was willing to step forward as a stepping stone, successfully separating their father and son, and finally Dong Zhuo was killed.

After that, Lu Bu was beheaded by Cao Cao, and the story of Diusim's whereabouts was never heard from again. First of all, we must affirm the story of diusim's appearance. Her wandering life is also lovely. Although she followed Dong Zhuo and others, her original kindness should be respected by us.

There is no narrative about her final destination in the novel, but the story of Guan Yu beheading Sim under the moon is mentioned in the zaju. After Lu Bu was killed, Cao Cao got her and gave it to Guan Yu, who finally killed her. Of course, this is just a folk story, and its truth is still unknown to us.

There are also many doubts. In fact, a general like Guan Yu should have no motive to kill Sim. This is more important. What can a weak woman have?

There are three different versions of this story.

First of all, the first one is the story of Cao Cao's determination to kill Deusim. It was unbearable to see people like Lu Bu Dong Zhuo, but no one was willing to give up, so Guan Yu was sent out.

Another one was dancing in the story of Diusim, and Guan Yu's broadsword undoubtedly fell, and the knife fell right on her shadow. It's amazing that it actually killed people through shadows.

And finally, we can see that Dong Zhuo and his son are related to the story of Diesim, and their final fate is also embarrassing. Under such circumstances, Guan Yu still has a certain profile in his heart, but he just doesn't want to kill him from the bottom of his heart. He just discovered such a secret, so he split into the shadow of Dixiem's story in the moonlight and urged her to leave quickly, otherwise he would not be able to save her. Soon Dixiem chose to commit suicide.