Is it illegal to grow vegetables on the roof terrace?

It is illegal to grow vegetables on the roof of a tall building.

First, if you build a house by yourself, you can plant vegetables on the roof, which can not only protect yourself from the sun, but also avoid rainwater leakage. However, if a high-rise building is a commercial housing community, it is generally not allowed to grow vegetables on the roof.

Second, some developers may claim to "buy the top floor and send it to the hanging garden", but in fact this sales method is illegal. The ownership of the roof space should be owned by all the owners. Therefore, if the developer and the top-level owner agree that the roof space belongs to their exclusive use, it shall be invalid and have no legal effect. Therefore, developers can neither own the roof space nor use it exclusively by the top-level owners through agreements.

Third, because the roof space above the top floor belongs to all owners, its possession, use, income and disposal are the rights of all owners, and are dominated by all owners. Even if the developer and individual owners reach an agreement, this agreement cannot hinder the rights of all owners.

Illegal acts are also called "invalid acts". An illegal act. Illegal behavior. Different from the objective illegal behavior, the actor is subjectively at fault when carrying out the behavior, thus infringing on the social relations protected by law. Subjective fault refers to the subjective state of intention or negligence. According to the nature of illegality, illegal acts can be divided into criminal violations, civil violations, economic violations and administrative violations. According to the degree of harm to society, illegal acts can be divided into general illegal acts and serious illegal acts (crimes)

Violation of law refers to an act that violates the current law and causes certain harm to society and is at fault. Illegal acts are divided into general illegal acts and serious illegal acts (that is, criminal acts) according to the seriousness of the circumstances. According to the laws it violates, it can be divided into administrative violations, civil violations, criminal violations and unconstitutional acts.

The concept of illegality has broad and narrow meanings. Broadly speaking, illegality refers to all acts that violate the existing laws, including general illegal acts and crimes. In a narrow sense, breaking the law refers to a serious violation of the law but does not constitute a crime. We are here to discuss illegality in a broad sense.

The connection between illegality and criminality is that crime must be illegal, and illegality is not necessarily a crime. The difference is that the degree of social harm of crime is more serious than that of illegal behavior. Most criminal acts bear criminal responsibility, while illegal acts bear administrative or civil responsibility.

Illegal acts are different from other acts. First of all, illegal behavior is different from immoral behavior. Many illegal acts are both criminal and immoral. However, not all illegal acts are immoral. Similarly, some immoral acts do not constitute illegal acts. Secondly, illegal acts are different from legally invalid acts. Of course, an illegal act can't produce the effective result that the perpetrator hoped when he committed the illegal act. However, it cannot be considered that all legally invalid acts are illegal. Although some legally invalid acts have no legal effect, they do not constitute illegality.

Legal basis:

Article 70 of the Property Law stipulates that the owners shall have the ownership of the exclusive parts of buildings such as business buildings, and the joint management right of the * * * parts other than the exclusive parts.

Article 71 of the Property Law stipulates that owners have the right to possess, use, benefit and dispose of the exclusive parts of their buildings. The exercise of rights by owners shall not endanger the safety of buildings or damage the legitimate rights and interests of other owners.