Review of Golden Broom Award

On June 7th, 2009,65438+February 7th, 2009, the nomination list of the first China's most disappointing film "Golden Broom Award" was jointly released by the editorial department of Youth Film Handbook and special film critics.

Winner list:

The most disappointing movies: Three Guns Surprise, Thorn Mausoleum and Nanjing! Nanjing! 》

The most disappointed director: Zhang Yimou's Three Guns Surprise and Lu Chuan's Nanjing! Nanjing! 》

The most disappointing hero: Xiao Shenyang's Three Guns Surprise

The most disappoint heroine: Lin Chi-ling's "that mausoleum with thorns"

Award ceremony:

201065438+1October 30th, the first China film "Golden Broom" award ceremony was held in Beijing SOHO Shangdu.

The award ceremony was kicked off by the performance of "Golden Broom" by young dancer Yu Xia and others. Pan Jie, a famous actor from a film family, presided over the ceremony and gathered more than 300 spectators at the scene.

Singers He Yi and Huang Qiwen sang songs for the awards evening. Actors Yi Chunde and Huang Lu, famous scholar Cui Weiping, directors Li Yu and Sheng Zhiming, famous critic Xie Xizhang and producer Li Fang delivered speeches for the award ceremony. Wang Xiaoshuai, a famous director, telephoned the award ceremony to express his support for the award. The audience sent a message to the winners, hoping that they would not continue to make bad films.

During the whole awarding process, none of the winners' representatives went to receive the award. The organizing Committee said that the trophy (broom model) and the award certificate will be mailed to the winners.

Although the winners have not arrived, the guest lineup is not weak. Producer Li Fang and Apple female directors Li Yu, actors Pan Jie, Huang Lu and Yi Chunde, and famous critics Cui Weiping and Xie Xizhang attended and presented various awards. Wang Xiaoshuai directed live telephone connection support activities. When Zhang Yimou was declared the most disappointing director, an audience received the Golden Broom Award for Zhang Yimou and delivered a speech: "I thank the judges on behalf of Zhang Yimou!" The audience burst into laughter. The audience also sent a message to the winners not to continue making bad films, which fully expressed the audience's keen concern for China's films, their fair evaluation of China's film industry, and their complex feelings of "deep love and responsibility" for China's film industry.

In addition to Three Guns Surprise, The Sting won two awards, the most disappointing film and the most disappointing actress (Lin Chi-ling). It is reported that the winners of this award are netizens and 20 independent film critics of Independent Review Salon. Different from previous awards, none of the winners of the Golden Broom Award received the award, but Cheng Qingsong said that he would mail the trophy (broom model) and the award certificate to all the winners.

While selecting the most disappointing films of the year, Youth Film Handbook recommended the top ten Chinese films in 2009, including You Can't Live Without, A Tale of Twenty-four Cities, The Story of Qingshui, Yang Yang Heard, Night and Fog in Tin Shui Wai, Bullfighting, Crazy Racing and so on. 2065438+001October 23rd, 10, the "Golden Broom Award", the worst film in China, jointly presented by Youth Film Handbook and Independent Film Critics, was selected by netizens, and the second shortlist was announced. The "Golden Broom Award" is selected for Chinese films released in the Mainland from 20 10 to1-0/2.

Winner list:

The most disappointing movies: Confucius, the legendary swordsman, If You Are the One 2;

The most disappointing directors: Hu Mei's Confucius and Xiaogang Feng's If You Are the One 2;

The most disappointed actor: Zhou Libo ("Tang Bohu points Chou-heung 2, Four Great Talents");

The most disappointed actress: Big S (Future Police, Jian Yu, Longfeng Store);

The most disappointing advertisement was placed in the film: Tangshan earthquake.

The most disappointing sequel remake: Tang Bohu points Chou-heung 2, the four great talents.

Award ceremony:

20 10 On February 22nd, the 2nd China Film Golden Broom Award, founded by Youth Film Handbook, was presented in Beijing. Many people in the film industry and enthusiastic audience attended. Confucius, Laughing Jianghu and If You Are the One 2 won the most disappointing film awards, while Hu Mei and Xiaogang Feng won the most disappointing director awards. Zhou Libo, the star of "Tong Bo Hu Dian Qiu Xiang 2", beat Xiao Shenyang and won the best actor "Golden Broom". Taiwan Province actress Da S was banned from three films: Future Police, Sword Rain and Dragon and Phoenix Store. This is an award ceremony without winners and lacking "acceptance speech", but the humorous acceptance speech of the organizer Ren Lei made the atmosphere very relaxed and conveyed the intention of the award to spur the growth of China films.

Media comments:

In 20 10, the box office of Chinese movies reached/kloc-0.02 billion yuan, but the audience's criticism of movies was also increasing, and as many as 20 movies were shortlisted for the second Golden Broom Award. Twenty disappointing films such as If You Are the One 2, Orphan Zhao, Love of Hawthorn Tree, Confucius, City Alert, Abandoned Apartment, Future Police, Face A and Face B were shortlisted. On the first day of online voting, "the legendary swordsman" and "Travel Notes of Xi" led the "most disappointing movies". Most directors of these films were shortlisted for the "Most Disappointing Directors" award, and Zhu Yanping and Zhang Yimou were shortlisted for the "Most Disappointing Directors" for two consecutive years.

In 20 10, China's films still lacked originality, and a large number of shoddy sequels appeared in remakes, while a large number of advertisements were stiffly embedded in the films, causing criticism from the audience. This year's Golden Broom Award added two awards: the most disappointing advertisement placement award and the most disappointing movie sequel. After the shortlist is announced, a comprehensive voting will begin online. Who will be the final winner is decided by netizens and independent filmmakers. The award will be announced at the award ceremony to be held at the end of February. The film critics of the main creators have said that at the time of the dazzling awards ceremony at the end of the year and the beginning of the year, "Golden Broom" hopes to select the film that most disappoints the audience, reminding filmmakers who are addicted to various grandiose awards, and it is urgent to improve the reputation of China films.

This year's tidbits:

Award-winning movies are not only "bad" but also blockbusters.

This year's Golden Broom Award was nominated by more than 40,000 viewers and netizens, and then the final result was selected by 3/kloc-0 film critics, media people and filmmakers.

There is a "threshold" for being nominated for the "Golden Broom Award". In addition to the film being "bad" enough, it also needs popularity. At least one of them can be a big production, a big director, a big star, a big publicity, a big fame and a big box office. So the winners are the "wrists" of the entertainment circle. 20 1 1, Zhang Yimou won the first prize in three shots, 20 12, it's Xiaogang Feng's turn to "sweep" the broom.

If You Are the One 2 won the most disappointing film award. The judges believe that although Fly 2 is a romantic comedy, what the audience finally sees is that "love" is a walk-on for "death", and Feng Dao won the most disappointing director award for this film. His other film "Tangshan Earthquake" won the most disappointing advertisement placement film award for its "explicit commercial advertisement placement".

The directors of Confucius, Hu Mei and Feng Dao, won the most disappointing director award. Together with Fly 2, the most disappointing movies of the year are Confucius and the legendary swordsman.

Zhou Libo and Big S won the title of "Empress"

In the year of 20 10, Big S diligently took over movies such as Sword Rain, Future Police, Longfeng Store, etc. There are many blockbuster works. But this year's Golden Broom Award is very popular with Big S. She was awarded the most disappointing actress award on the grounds that "Big S's performance is like crying, crying like laughing, and her performance is too modern and jumping." After being nominated for the first Golden Broom Most Disappointing Actress Award, this big S was finally sealed.

The most disappointing "film emperor" was accidentally taken away by Shanghai-style Qingkou Zhou Libo. He tried to play a supporting role in "Tang Bohu Dian Qiu Xiang 2" and "Dragon and Phoenix Hall", but obviously his acting skills were not as good as his green mouth. The judges were not very polite about him: "Zhou Libo tried to cover up his poor acting skills on the big screen with his nonsense stage performance style." This kind of speculative performance that he thinks can tickle the audience can't escape the tragic fate of expressing wrong feelings. " It is reported that in the voting session, Zhou Libo's votes are more than twice that of other candidates such as Xiao Shenyang and He Jiong. The judges also had to "urge" Zhou Libo, who was drinking coffee, to "tune a tune" in the film performance.

No one will receive prizes in the mail.

There are still no winners to receive the prize at this award ceremony. In this regard, Cheng Qingsong, the editor-in-chief of Youth Film Handbook, the organizer of the event, said: "The day before the award ceremony, we convened every winner. There really was a winner who promised to come to the scene, but a few hours before the award, he said something was wrong. I will mail the trophy to the winner. " Winner list:

The most disappointing movies: The Warring States, The Legend of Amazon and Guan Yunchang.

The most disappointing small and medium-sized movie: No.32 in B District, traffic jam.

The most disappointing film jury special award: "flowers of war"

The most disappointed directors: Gao's Da Wusheng and The Legend of Amazon.

Most Disappointed Actor: Sun's The Wind and Cloud of the Warring States.

The most disappoint actress: Cecilia Cheung's legendary Amazon Valley and priceless.

The most disappointing collective performance: Eason Chan, Karen Mok, Zhong Zhentao, Crystal, Ekin Cheng, Sitar tan, etc.

The most disappointing cartoon: Xibaipo

The most disappointing imported movie: The Green Hornet.

Final judges: Sun, Xie Xizhang, Li Jing,,,, Huang Ou, Song Jianjun, Wang Yang, Chen Bin, Wang Peng, Yang Lu, Yu Deqing, Wang Bo, Zeng Nianqun, Lao Huang, Tan Fei, Yang Jinsong, A Shun, Mei Xuefeng and Jia Jian.

Award ceremony:

20 12 On March 3rd, the 3rd Golden Broom Award for Bad Films was presented in Beijing. Sun was called the most disappointing actress because of her performance in the Warring States Policy, and was called the most disappointing actress because of her performance in two films, Young Woman and Priceless Treasure. Eason Chan, Karen Mok, Zhong Zhentao, Crystal, Ekin Cheng and Sitar tan were rated as "the most disappointing collective performances" for their performances in "East West 20 1 1".

Gao He was named "the most disappointing director" for their films "Da Wusheng" and "Young Woman". In addition, the most disappointing small and medium budget films are No.32 in Zone B and Traffic Jam, the most disappointing cartoon is Xibaipo, and the most disappointing imported film is The Green Hornet.

None of the winners came to receive the prize. Organizers said that Sitar tan and Richie Jen had said that if they had time to win the prize, they would "accept the prize" in the future to motivate themselves. In order to make this award process more interesting, the organizer specially asked the staff to wear Sun He's poster to "receive the award". Winner list:

Most Disappointing Movies: The Guillotine, The Roar of Lions 2, The King's Feast

The most disappointing small and medium-sized movie: crazy stupid thief, car on the road.

Most Disappointed Directors: Ma Weihao (The Lion Roar 2) and Lu Chuan (The King's Feast).

The most disappointed actor: Xiao Shenyang (Griffin 2).

The most disappointing actress: Yang Mi (the classic of Wudang heaven and earth, holding love)

Final judges: Ming Jiang, Ye Min, Zhang Yi, Mud, Wang Peng, Yu Deqing, Sai Ren, Wang Yang, Hou Zhihui, Huang Ou, Ye Kuangzheng, Sun Laohuang, Hu Bugui, Sun Jinmeng, Yang Jinsong, Yang Lu, Li Duoyu, A Shun, Mei Xuefeng and Jia Jian.

Select time:

The first round of voting, the voting time is120 on October 9th1365438+to 24: 00 on February 9th. The results of the second round of voting will be announced at the 4th China Film Golden Broom Awards Ceremony on March 3rd, 20th/KLOC-0th/3rd. All the short-listed films are China films released or sold in Chinese mainland in 20 12 (65438+ 101-65438+February 3 1).

Results announced:

The fourth China film "Golden Broom Award" online voting has come to an end, and the shortlists of five awards, such as "the most disappointing film" and "the most disappointing actor (actress)", have been released. In terms of works, "Lion Roar 2" and "Wudang Heaven and Earth Code" lead the way; As for actors, Yang Mi and Xiao Shenyang won the first prize.

As for the "most disappointing actress", Yang Mi, who leads with 208,328 votes, is not far behind Cecilia Cheung and Jing Tian, who are ranked second and third. This is also the "second finalist" of Cecilia Cheung and Tian Jing in the "Golden Broom Award". In terms of actors, Xiao Shenyang and Degang Guo continued the previous cross-border artists' list. Xiao Shenyang, who was favored by Golden Broom twice, was selected as the "Worst Actor" in The Lion Roar 2 with Three Guns and the legendary swordsman. On the other hand, Degang Guo ranked second with 9,250 votes, following Xiao Shenyang. Chiu Man-Cheuk was selected for the first time by virtue of Wudang's laws of heaven and earth. 20 13 Awards ceremony announced on March 3rd.

Award ceremony: Ma Weihao sent representatives to receive the award. The producer of Crazy Stupid Thief made a public comment in Li Mingyang.

There was an unexpected scene at the award ceremony. In previous years, the "Golden Broom Award" was awarded, and almost none of the winners received the award. However, when the "Most Disappointing Director" award was presented this time, Ma Weihao's colleagues suddenly took the stage, not only accepting the award for him, but also entrusting Ma Weihao to deliver his acceptance speech.

Coincidentally, when the "Most Disappointing Movie" award was presented, Li Mingyang, the producer of "Crazy Stupid Thief", suddenly appeared, read a three-minute apology letter and sincerely bowed to the national movie audience. "Through this award, I will sum up my experience and use this golden broom to sweep away my impetuousness and dust."

This year's "Golden Broom Award" won a lot of praise for its breakthrough in entrusting the parties to receive the award. Some film critics said that China filmmakers are responsible and mature in the face of different voices from fans, film critics and the media. "Applause is not necessarily a good thing; Listen to criticism and develop. "

After the award ceremony, on March 6, 20 13, Xiao Shenyang, who won the most disappointing actor, also responded in the Weibo: Golden broom, do what you should do. I will accept the award with an open mind! I sincerely admit that it's really bad! This is also my encouragement and experience in the future. More than 2 million people voted, which proves that there are still people concerned! I accept criticism and hope everyone will encourage me. Come on! See you on the way back. Bow! Winner list:

Most Disappointing Film Awards: Fuchun Shan Jutu, Tiny Times Series, Private Customization.

The most disappointing small and medium budget film awards: Happy Home, I am a blind date freak and far cry 2.

The most disappointing director awards: Fuchun Shan Jutu by Sun Jianjun and Tiny Times by Jing M.Guo.

The most disappointed screenwriter: Wang Shuo and personal tailor.

Most Disappointing Actor Awards: Du Haitao's Happy Home and I'm a blind date freak.

The most disappointing actress award: Jing Tian's special identity and never give up 20 13.

Award ceremony:

On March 201April 8/KLOC-0, the 5th China Film Golden Broom Award was held in Fanhai Concert Hall. Du Haitao and Jing Tian won the most disappointing actor and actress awards of the year. Although the organizing Committee actively communicated with all the winners and winners, it was a pity that no one attended.

According to Cheng Qingsong, the founder of the Golden Broom Award, the organizer's staff sent a notice of winning the award to Jing Tian, but the other party hung up as soon as they heard the "Golden Broom". The organizer also sent a text message inviting that "this is a positive thing, and I look forward to Jing Tian's participation", but the other party did not respond. Du Haitao staff said that they could not participate in the recording of Happy Camp that day. But I sent my acceptance speech to the organizer.

Ann An, the producer of the film Tiny Times 1 2, said: "Tiny Times 1 2 was a controversial film in 20 13 years. I will learn from it and urge myself to make better movies, regardless of praise or blame. " Fu Huayang, the director of the movie Happy Home, sent a special acceptance speech: "Winning the Golden Broom Award is really shocking. I began to find that I lost my heart in this decade, because I couldn't control myself. I didn't spend my time paying attention to people's livelihood, polishing scripts, making fine works and artistic innovation. I lost my soul, my respect for film creation and my communication with the audience. The public voting stage of the 6th Golden Broom Award officially ended. There are 9 voting platforms in this year's Golden Broom Award. In addition to the traditional online voting, there are also new media voting platforms such as Weibo and WeChat.

Winner list:

The most disappointing movies: The White-haired Witch, Tinea 3: The Golden Age and breakup guru.

The most disappointing small and medium-sized movie: Where is Dad going? Big talk, cosmetic diary.

The most disappointing directors: Zhang Zhiliang (White-haired Witch) and Jing M.Guo (Tiny Age 3: Golden Age).

The most disappointing screenwriter: Jing M.Guo (Tiny Times 3: The Golden Age)

Most Disappointed Actor: Donnie Yen (Frozen: Journey to the West)

The most disappointing actress: Yang Mi (Tiny Times 3: Golden Age, breakup guru)

Award ceremony:

On March 201May 16, the 6th China Film "Golden Broom Award" and the Youth Film Handbook "Top Ten Chinese Awards Ceremony" were held in Beijing. The film Tiny Times 3 led the Golden Broom, and the "Most Disappointing" award occupied 4 seats. Yang Mi and Donnie Yen won the Golden Broom Award for the most disappointing actor and actress of the year, but neither of them attended the ceremony.

Cheng Qingsong, the founder, said: "China films are in the best times and the worst times. 20 14 The total box office of China movies is close to 30 billion yuan, but the box office is not the only criterion to measure the film level. In the past year, the embarrassing scenes of box office and bad film Qi Fei can be seen everywhere, so we urgently need a' golden broom' to sweep away the dust in the film industry and encourage China filmmakers. "

Since its birth, the golden broom has been puzzled, pressured and even vilified by the outside world, and the shortage of funds has been struggling. It is understood that the Golden Broom Award not only represents the opinions of netizens, but also has a professional attitude. More than 1.3 million netizens voted to select the top ten finalists, and then an expert group composed of 25 film critics, media people, screenwriters and scholars selected the final result. Winner list:

The most disappointing movies: falling from the sky, villain angel and gardenia blossom.

The most disappointing small and medium-sized movie: Running Man, where is Dad going? 2. If you love me, go to the movies with me.

Most Disappointed Directors: He Jiong (Gardenia Blossoms), Wei Nan and Min Wei (Catastrophe from Heaven).

The most disappointed screenwriter: Yu Baimei (villain angel)

The most disappointed actor: Deng Chao (villain angel)

The most disappointing actress: Yang Mi (Tiny Times 4: How to Be Silent at the End of the Soul)

Award ceremony:

On March 20th, 20 16, the award ceremony of "Top Ten Chinese in 20 15" and the 7th Golden Broom Award were held in Beijing. The villain angel directed and starred by Deng Chao became the biggest winner of the 7th Golden Broom Award, winning the most disappointing film and the most disappointing film in one fell swoop. Another winner, Yang Mi, won the "Most Disappointing Actress" for her performances in Tiny Times 4: The End of the Soul and Why Shengxiao Mo. This is the third time that she has won the title of "the most disappointing actress".

The "Golden Broom Award" was nominated by netizens, and then a group of 25 film critics, media people, screenwriters and scholars voted for the final result. This year's "Golden Broom Award" still has no winners.